Carpet vs. Hardwood: Choosing the Best Flooring for Bedrooms

hardwood and carpet options for your bedroom

Disclaimer: This post may contain references, affiliate links, or links to products from one or more partners of our parent company and/or subsidiaries of our parent company. You can learn more here.

You’re creating the perfect bedroom, and you’ve come to one of the most important decisions: choosing the right flooring. Your bedroom’s flooring sets the foundation for the space’s overall look, feel, and comfort. Among the countless flooring options, carpet and hardwood are two of the most popular bedroom choices. Today, we help you choose between them (or maybe even choose another option).

Ready to start shopping?
While there’s a lot of great info to gather here, both are great options, and you might just need to find your perfect flooring by shopping. Here are a couple of our favorites:

Carpet: Proximity MillsVisit Their SiteFind a Retailer
Hardwood: DomaVisit Their SiteFind a Retailer

The Age Old Battle: Carpet vs. Hardwood in Bedrooms

The Cozy Comfort of Carpet

The history of carpet in American bedrooms started over 200 years ago at the first woven carpet mill in Philadelphia. Today, carpets remain a popular choice for bedroom flooring, offering a cozy and inviting atmosphere while showcasing a wide range of styles and materials to suit individual tastes and preferences.

Minimalist bedroom with soft, inviting carpet

Pros of Carpet in Bedrooms:

Supreme Comfort: Carpet is renowned for its soft and cushioned feel underfoot, making it a top choice for those who value comfort in their bedrooms. It’s particularly inviting for kids who enjoy playing on the floor.

Warmth: Carpet helps maintain a warm and cozy atmosphere in the bedroom, especially during cold winter. It provides natural insulation, reducing heat loss through the floor.

Noise Reduction: If you live in a multi-story building or have noisy neighbors, carpet can help dampen sound, creating a quieter and more peaceful bedroom environment.

Cons of Carpet in Bedrooms:

Maintenance: The carpet requires regular vacuuming and occasional deep cleaning to prevent the buildup of dust, allergens, and stains. It may not be the best choice for those with allergies.

Durability & Stain Resistance: Carpet may wear out more quickly than hardwood, especially in high-traffic areas like the bedroom doorway, and spills and accidents can leave permanent stains on carpets.

The Timeless Elegance of Hardwood

The oldest hardwood floors can be traced back to ancient Egypt, around 3,0000 BC. This flooring method continued to grow for thousands of years, and by the mid-20th century, hardwood flooring had become a symbol of timeless elegance and a staple in bedrooms worldwide. Today, it continues to be a preferred choice for bedroom decor, blending tradition with modern style and offering enduring beauty and warmth.

Elegant hardwood flooring in a primary bedroom

Pros of Hardwood in Bedrooms:

Durability: Hardwood is known for its longevity. When properly cared for, hardwood can last for decades, making upfront costs worth it in the long run

Easy Maintenance: Maintaining hardwood flooring is relatively easy; frequent sweeping and occasional mopping are often all it takes to keep them looking great.

Aesthetic Appeal: Wood flooring exudes elegance and adds a timeless, upscale look to any bedroom. Its natural beauty enhances the overall aesthetics of the space.

Cons of Hardwood in Bedrooms:

Cost: Hardwood flooring can be expensive in terms of material and installation. However, its durability can offset this initial investment.

Coldness: Hardwood can feel cold underfoot, which might not be ideal for those in colder climates. Area rugs can help mitigate this issue.

Noise: Hardwood floors amplify sound rather than dampen it, so footsteps and other noises may be more noticeable.

Area Rugs: The Perfect Compromise

Area rugs offer myriad benefits that could make them the perfect compromise for those torn between the comfort of carpet and the elegance of hardwood in their bedrooms. By strategically placing area rugs, you can expect the following benefits.

Stylish bedroom interior design with hardwood and an area rug

Design Flexibility

Area rugs come in various colors, patterns, and textures, making them versatile design elements. They let you personalize your bedroom’s look and feel without committing to a permanent flooring choice. If you change your decor, swapping out an area rug is much easier than ripping up and replacing carpet.

Noise Reduction

As mentioned earlier, hardwood floors can amplify sound. Area rugs help dampen noise, making them an excellent choice for creating a quieter and more serene bedroom environment. This is especially beneficial in shared living spaces or multi-story homes.

Easy Maintenance

Area rugs are generally easier to clean and maintain than wall-to-wall carpet. Regular vacuuming and occasional spot cleaning are sufficient to keep them in good condition. Plus, if a rug becomes damaged or stained, you can replace it without extensive repairs.

Seasonal Adaptability

In some climates, you may want to change the feel of your bedroom seasonally. Area rugs provide an easy way to switch between a warm, cozy atmosphere in the winter and a cooler, lighter feel in the summer. Simply roll up or replace the rug as needed.

Protection for Hardwood

Area rugs also serve as a protective layer for hardwood floors. They can prevent scratches, scuffs, and wear in high-traffic areas, helping to extend the lifespan of your hardwood flooring.

Further Considerations for Bedroom Flooring

Cost & Resale Value

Carpet tends to be more budget-friendly than hardwood regarding material and installation. However, it’s important to factor in the ongoing expenses of carpet, such as regular cleaning and potential replacement due to wear and stains. Hardwood often comes with a higher upfront cost, but its durability and longevity can make it a better choice in the long run, as it may require less frequent replacement and maintenance and is typically regarded as the flooring option that adds the most home value.

Lifestyle and Use

Your lifestyle and how you intend to use the bedroom are essential factors. If your bedroom is primarily a space for relaxation, sleep, and minimal foot traffic, the comfort and warmth of the carpet may be ideal. However, hardwood’s durability and easy maintenance could be more practical if your bedroom serves as a multi-purpose area, including a home office or exercise space.

Allergies and Health Concerns

If you or anyone in your household has allergies or asthma, it’s crucial to consider the impact of your flooring choice on indoor air quality. Carpets can trap allergens, dust mites, and pet dander, making them less suitable for allergy sufferers. Hardwood, however, is hypoallergenic and easier to keep clean, reducing the potential for allergen buildup.

Maintenance Commitment

How much time and energy do you want to put into your flooring? Carpets require frequent cleaning and maintenance, including vacuuming and occasional professional cleaning. Hardwood floors are easier day to day but may require refinishing every few years to maintain their appearance.

Beyond Carpet and Hardwood: Other Flooring Options for Bedrooms

While carpet and hardwood are the most popular choices for bedroom flooring, other options are worth considering. These alternatives can offer unique benefits and aesthetics:

Stylish bedroom with laminate flooring

Laminate Flooring

Leaning towards hardwood but worried about the cost? Laminate is easy to maintain and quite durable, making it a practical choice for bedrooms. However, it doesn’t offer the same warmth and natural feel as real hardwood.

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring comes in various styles, including vinyl plank flooring that mimics hardwood. It’s affordable, easy to clean, and can be a suitable choice for bedrooms. However, it may have a different resale value than hardwood or the comfort of carpet.

Cork Flooring

Cork is an eco-friendly and soft flooring option. It’s comfortable to walk on, naturally insulating, and resistant to allergens. Cork can add a unique and sustainable touch to your bedroom.

Tile Flooring

Tile is a durable and low-maintenance option. It’s ideal for warm climates and an excellent choice for a sleek, modern look in your bedroom. However, it can feel cold underfoot and may not be as comfortable as carpet or cork.

Decided on the best bedroom flooring?

Selecting the best flooring for your bedroom is a decision that should consider both practicality and aesthetics. While carpet and hardwood remain popular, other flooring options offer unique benefits and may better suit your specific needs and preferences.

Ultimately, the best flooring for your bedroom depends on your lifestyle, budget, climate, and design style. By carefully evaluating these factors you can make an informed choice that creates a comfortable and visually pleasing bedroom retreat. Take your time, explore your options, and choose the flooring that makes your bedroom the perfect haven you’ve always dreamed of.

Choosing hardwood over carpet? Check out our guide here on The 10 Best Hardwood Flooring Brands in 2023